What are the Rules of Engagement in Penetration Testing?

The term “Rules of Engagement” might sound intimidating at first, but It’s simply a set of guidelines designed to protect both you as the client and the team performing the testing. The Rules of Engagement, or ROE, clearly outline the details of your penetration testing project.

‍

This includes what will be tested, when the testing will happen, and how it will be carried out. The ROE serves as a clear description of the testing process, making sure everyone involved understands what is happening.

Rules of Engagement for Penetration Testing

Rules of Engagement (RoE) for penetration testing are predefined guidelines that outline how the test will be conducted. They help align expectations between the organization and the testing team to ensure security, legal compliance, and minimal operational disruption.

‍

Here are the key components of RoE:

‍

Scope Definition

‍

A well-defined scope is the foundation of a successful penetration test. It sets the boundaries for what will and will not be tested. This  helps minimize risk and maximize the relevance of the findings.

‍

In-Scope Assets

In-scope assets are the systems, services, and environments explicitly authorized for testing. These assets represent the attack surface that an adversary could realistically target. These typically include:

‍

• IP Addresses: Public or internal IP ranges, including DMZ and corporate networks.
• Domains and Subdomains: Web properties owned or managed by the organization.
• Cloud Services: AWS, Azure, GCP environments, containers, serverless functions, and managed services like S3 or Azure Blob.
• Web and Mobile Applications: Front-end portals, admin panels, APIs, and mobile backends.
• APIs and Microservices: REST, GraphQL, or gRPC endpoints that handle critical business logic or user data.

‍

Out-of-Scope Assets

Out-of-scope assets are systems excluded from the engagement due to potential operational impact, legal limitations, or lack of ownership. These may include:

‍

• Third-Party Platforms: Services not under your direct control (unless permission has been granted).
• Production Systems with High Uptime Requirements: Core transactional databases or payment gateways.
• Employee Devices: Unless explicitly covered under a red team or insider threat simulation.
• Legacy Systems: Platforms that may crash or lose data when probed.

‍

Timeframe

‍

The Timeframe defines exactly when the penetration testing activities will occur. A clear timeline ensures transparency, coordination with internal teams, and minimal disruption to business operations, especially in production environments.

‍

Every penetration test must operate within an explicitly agreed-upon start and end date. This scheduled window allows all stakeholders to align internal monitoring teams, and ensure key personnel are available if any issues arise.

‍

ioSENTRIX works closely with clients to:

‍

• Account for holidays, maintenance schedules, and compliance cycles.
• Select a window that fits organizational operations and minimizes business impact.
• Build in time for pre-engagement briefings and post-assessment retesting if needed.
  
  

Penetration testing may generate alerts or affect system performance, so it’s essential to specify when testing can occur:

‍

• Business Hours Testing: Ideal for internal systems and scenarios where team coordination is needed in real-time.
• After-Hours Testing: Often used for external infrastructure or when there's a need to avoid interfering with business-critical operations.

‍

Testing Methodology

‍

The Testing Methodology defines the depth and style of testing, as well as the tools and tactics that will (or will not) be used. This ensures all activities remain aligned with the organization’s risk tolerance, compliance obligations, and operational constraints.

‍

The RoE clearly states the type of penetration test to be conducted based on the client's objectives and available information:

‍

• Black-Box Testing: The tester has no prior knowledge of the environment. This simulates an external attacker trying to breach systems from the outside.
• White-Box Testing: Full access is granted, including credentials, source code, or architectural documentation. This is ideal for in-depth code reviews and architecture-level analysis.
• Gray-Box Testing: The tester receives limited internal knowledge (e.g., login credentials, user roles) to simulate an attacker with insider access or compromised credentials.

‍

Risk Management

‍

It defines how potential risks are identified, mitigated, and controlled during the penetration testing process. Penetration testing often involves interaction with live systems and real data. The RoE must clearly outline how to handle sensitive or production data to prevent accidental exposure or legal violations.

‍

ioSENTRIX follows strict guidelines to ensure:

‍

• No unauthorized access to personal or regulated data (e.g., PII, PHI, PCI).
• Data masking or anonymization is applied when interacting with sensitive environments.
• Testing credentials and access tokens are isolated from production user accounts.
• Client approval is obtained before testing high-risk data flows, such as payment systems or healthcare APIs.

‍

Read more on: What is Risk Mitigation? Definition and Strategies for Businesses.

‍

Penetration testing may inadvertently trigger alerts or degrade system performance. The RoE outlines specific impact controls to manage and contain these risks:

‍

• Predefined Escalation Paths: If an anomaly is detected, ioSENTRIX immediately alerts the designated security contacts.
• Alert Suppression Planning: SOC teams are briefed on what traffic to expect to prevent misidentification.
• Service Disruption Avoidance: High-impact tests (e.g., stress testing, privilege escalation) are simulated or conducted in non-production environments unless explicitly approved.
• Live Incident Response Triggers: If a system enters a critical state, testing is paused and assessed jointly with the client.

‍

‍

Communication Plan

‍

The Communication Plan is a critical component and establishes how information will flow during the penetration test. A solid communication plan prevents miscommunication, reduces downtime, and keeps all stakeholders aligned throughout the engagement.

‍

To streamline coordination, the RoE clearly identifies primary points of contact on both the client and testing team sides. These individuals are responsible for:

‍

• Responding to time-sensitive queries.
• Authorizing scope clarifications or real-time test adjustments.
• Facilitating access to systems, credentials, or documentation if needed.
  
  

Each contact should have defined availability, preferred communication channels (e.g., email, phone, secure chat), and backup contacts in case of unavailability.

‍

The RoE also outlines how and when vulnerabilities or incidents should be reported during the engagement. ioSENTRIX follows a structured, client-approved incident handling process that includes:

‍

• Real-Time Alerts: For critical vulnerabilities (e.g., remote code execution, privilege escalation), the client is notified immediately to prevent exploitation.
• Daily or Interim Status Updates: Provide visibility into ongoing findings and testing progress.
• Secure Reporting Channels: All communications and findings are shared over encrypted channels.
• Post-Engagement Review: A final debrief is conducted to walk through all findings, clarify questions, and discuss remediation steps.

‍

Authorization and Legal Clearance

‍

The Authorization and Legal Clearance ensures that all penetration testing activities are legally sanctioned and fully documented. This protects both the client and the testing team from legal liability, contractual violations, and misunderstandings with third parties.

‍

Before any testing begins, ioSENTRIX requires formal written authorization from the client. This signed consent form is a legal document that:

‍

• Grants explicit permission to test the agreed-upon assets.
• Clearly identifies the scope, objectives, and timeline of the engagement.
• Protects the client and ioSENTRIX from unauthorized access claims or legal disputes.

‍

Many modern environments rely on third-party platforms or cloud infrastructure (e.g., AWS, Azure, GCP). If these systems are part of the engagement, the RoE must include provisions to:

‍

• Notify third-party providers (such as cloud vendors) in accordance with their penetration testing policies.
• Obtain necessary permissions from service providers to avoid breaching terms of service.
• Coordinate with vendors to prevent misinterpretation of tests as real attacks, which could trigger automated defenses or legal actions.
  
  

ioSENTRIX supports clients in managing these third-party notifications and, when needed, can provide templated communications or assist in securing approval.

‍

You may find interesting: What is Cloud Penetration Testing Process?

‍

Reporting Expectations

‍

Reporting explains how the progress will be communicated throughout the engagement and what the client can expect in the final deliverables. This ensures transparency and guarantees the report is structured for both technical and executive audiences.

‍

Depending on the complexity and duration of the engagement, ioSENTRIX may provide daily or weekly status updates. These updates typically include:

‍

• A summary of activities completed.
• Preliminary findings of interest or concern.
• Immediate notifications for critical or high-risk vulnerabilities.
• Any blockers or access issues that may affect testing progress.
  
  

Interim updates keep stakeholders in the loop and minimize surprises at the end of the engagement.

‍

The final report is the cornerstone of the penetration testing engagement. It is a professionally structured document that includes:

‍

• Executive Summary: A high-level overview for leadership, covering objectives, key findings, business impact, and overall risk posture.
• Technical Findings: Detailed vulnerability descriptions, CVSS scoring, risk ratings, proof-of-concept evidence, and screenshots.
• Remediation Guidance: Recommendations for fixing each issue, including best practices and references.
• Reproduction Steps: Step-by-step instructions to validate or retest vulnerabilities.
• Vulnerability Tracker: A spreadsheet-format appendix to help track remediation status across internal teams.
  
  

All reporting is delivered securely and can be customized to align with the client’s internal reporting standards or compliance requirements (e.g., PCI-DSS, ISO 27001, SOC 2).

‍

Remediation and Retesting

‍

This section outlines what happens after the initial penetration test is completed. This phase ensures that identified vulnerabilities are not only addressed but also validated through follow-up testing.

‍

Once the client has implemented the recommended fixes, ioSENTRIX offers a targeted retesting service to confirm the effectiveness of the remediation efforts. The RoE defines:

‍

• Which vulnerabilities will be retested: Typically, all high and critical findings, along with any medium issues that were prioritized by the client.
• When retesting will occur: Scheduled in coordination with the client after a reasonable patching window (often 2–4 weeks post-report).
• How results will be verified: Using the same methods and tools from the initial test to ensure consistency and accuracy.

‍

Additionally, a Retest Addendum Report is provided, clearly stating which issues were resolved, which remain open, and any new findings introduced during the patching process.

Frequently Asked Questions

‍

What are the rules of engagement in penetration testing?

‍

A Rules of Engagement document is created and signed by both parties. It explains what is included in the testing project. Typically, it outlines the areas that will be tested for vulnerabilities, considering how much damage could happen. The testing is also done in coordination with the customer to ensure everything is clear and agreed upon.

‍

What are the rules of engagement for security?

‍

Rules of Engagement (ROE) are clear guidelines that show the intent of actions, based on legal, policy, and operational considerations specific to a situation. They are made to ensure that any use of force is carried out in a way that is legally permitted.

‍

What is the rule of engagement in cybersecurity?

‍

The Rules of Engagement (ROE) provide detailed rules and limits for carrying out information security testing. The ROE is set before the testing begins and gives the testing team permission to perform specific activities without needing to ask for further approval.

‍